The shape of the original tree suggested the form of spreading wings which inspired sculptor Brad Rhea to sculpt the tree trunk into his beautiful version of a caterpillar spinning a cocoon which bursts into a butterfly ready to take flight. This piece is frequently referred to as the butterfly by many locals. The original owners of the sculpture donated it to NJC.

The college and the Logan County Chamber of Commerce raised money to restore the original sculpture and at that time, it was moved inside. A bronze replica now graces the lawn at the visitor's center.